Training the dog to lie or stand, on the stop command

Should the dog lie down, or remain standing, when you stop it?

We're often asked whether a working sheepdog should lie on the ground, or remain standing when it receives a stop command. Logically, a dog that receives the "lie down" command should lie on the floor, and one which is told to "stand" should remain on its feet.

Working sheepdog lying in the grass, close to the sheep
There's a dog lying in the grass behind the sheep in this picture. (Far right). Click the image to enlarge it.

If you leave it up to the sheepdog itself, whether to stand or lie down on the stop command, some will remain on their feet, and some will naturally prefer to lie down (whatever the command).

Sheepdog Carew standing as she holds her sheep
Carew at work - I like a dog to remain on its feet when it's herding sheep. Click image to enlarge.

Personally, I much prefer a dog to remain on its feet - simply because a dog which is already standing up, can surely move more quickly than one which has to get up off the ground first. Therefore, a young trainee dog that's encouraged to remain upright, will hopefully feel more confident of being able to dodge away from trouble if the sheep are aggressive. Confidence is paramount in a sheepdog.

It's not a big deal though - one of my best bitches (Kay) nearly always lies down, and she has no problem with aggressive sheep.

Some trainers insist on the dog actually lying down when they say lie down, and standing when they say stand, but to me, this is unnecessarily strict. The dog should learn what's required in a given situation, from the urgency in your voice, and a good dog will act accordingly. Beginners, on the other hand, often prefer the dog to lie down, because a dog lying on the ground gives the impression it's going to stay there for a while, and the trainer feels they can relax a little.

There are no hard and fast rules on it, and it's interesting to watch different reactions from different dogs (and trainers) under similar circumstances.

To further complicate matters, I prefer to use "lie down" as my stop command, even though I prefer the dog to remain on its feet. The dogs are perfectly happy with this, because they know no different, but some of those who attend our sheepdog training courses are a little puzzled by it, but as I see it, "stand" begins with 's' and as such, must begin with a hissing sound. Hissing and shushing sounds are frequently used (by me and a great many other sheepdog trainers) to excite, motivate, or speed dogs on their way. This would seem to be in conflict with the result we're expecting.


Learn more about how to train a sheepdog with our Online Sheepdog Training Videos


A dog's brain works many times faster than a human's, and in my opinion, sometimes, "stand" (especially when the 's' is prolonged) can give the dog conflicting messages. Watching keen young dogs react to my telling them to "come here" when we're close to sheep, has proven this to me time and again. Just the letter 'c' is enough to trigger the dog into a "come-bye" outrun, but within a fraction of a second, the dog will realise what I actually meant, and will come back to me, often looking apologetic.

Call it petty if you like, but I like to eliminate every confusing factor when I start training a young sheepdog, so I use "Lie down" spoken as softly as the situation allows, to give trainee dogs a clear signal that I want them to stop.


  • FIRST STEPS IN BORDER COLLIE SHEEPDOG TRAINING
    FROM CHAOS TO CONTROL!
    2xDVD set. Watch the Preview Here

    Click icon at bottom-right of viewer for full-screen mode.

    Learn how to train your first sheepdog with the 2xDVD set that shows sheepdog training as it really is! As well as clear instruction on what to do, you'll see things going wrong and how to put them right. More info
    We automatically ship the correct format for your location. Choice of six currencies to pay in! | Buy NOW

    © Images, video, articles and text on this website are protected by copyright laws and must not be reproduced without the owner's written permission.

2 thoughts on “Training the dog to lie or stand, on the stop command”

  1. I find I use the “Stand” command for Jock, which stops him in his tracks (most times) and he remains on his feet. If the sheep are stopped and I need them to stay where they are, I’ll tell him to “Drop”. This has the added advantage that the sheep tend to relax a little (which I need at times so I can look over them without having to yard them (no touching, just looking) and it tells Jock that he has to stay where he is (very handy when he’s overly enthusiastic). I’ve never used “lie-down”, however I’ve always been taught (before now) to use ‘one word commands’. I prefer Jock to stay on his feet unless I tell him otherwise. As with all commands I give, softly spoken is encouraging, grumpy/growling means “do as you’re told, NOW”. Regarding the directions, I’m finding I use Way (instead of away), and all I have to say is “Come” (don’t usually get the Bye bit out) and Jock is off. The only issue I have now, is I don’t have a ‘walk-up’ command, because the minute I say “Wa”, he thinks he has to counter-clockwise. Live and learn I guess!

    BTW: Excellent post (as always) Andy, it helps me to understand why some people do what they do.

We'd love to read your comments -